Vitamin C and Membrane Permeability (Core Practicals 2 and 3): Edexcel SNAB A Level Biology Exam Questions

Core Practical 2 asks you to investigate the vitamin C content of food and drink: a set volume of blue DCPIP is titrated against the juice or extract until it turns colourless, and the volume needed is compared with a standard vitamin C solution or a calibration curve. Core Practical 3 asks you to investigate membrane structure, including the effect of alcohol concentration or temperature on membrane permeability: beetroot sections of the same size are placed in each solution and the betalain pigment that leaks out is measured with a colorimeter. These questions come from real Edexcel A level Biology A (Salters-Nuffield) papers. Core practicals can be examined on any paper, but Paper 3 at A level tests practical skills most heavily. Questions marked AS are from the AS papers (8BN0); the rest are from the A level papers (9BN0).

The examiners' reports say many students could recall the practical but did not apply it to the new context, such as cabbage leaves, breast milk or cooked broccoli. Describe a real titration, not counting drops from a pipette, know the DCPIP colour change, and explain how the volume becomes a vitamin C concentration. Include an uncooked sample when cooking is tested. For membranes, explain rather than describe: alcohol dissolves membrane lipids, so permeability rises and betalain diffuses out. Know the difference between a control and a controlled variable, and choose a suitable range for the independent variable.

Studying Edexcel SNAB and want more help? If you'd like to arrange one-to-one Edexcel tutoring, or to register your interest in an Edexcel group class, message Tom on WhatsApp using the link at the bottom of this page.

What you need first

Each question on this page assumes you're secure on these ideas. If any of them feels shaky, look it up before you start.

  • Cell membranes are made of a phospholipid bilayer with proteins, as described by the fluid mosaic model.
  • Vitamin C is a reducing agent that decolourises blue DCPIP.
  • A titration adds one solution from a burette to a measured volume of another until an end point is reached.
  • A colorimeter measures how much light a coloured solution absorbs; more pigment means higher absorbance.

Key terms

These words come up in the questions and mark schemes. Examiners expect you to use them exactly.

  • DCPIP: a blue dye that turns colourless when vitamin C is added; used to measure vitamin C content.
  • End point: the point in a titration when the colour change happens, such as DCPIP turning from blue to colourless.
  • Calibration curve: a graph made from solutions of known vitamin C concentration, used to read off the concentration in an unknown sample.
  • Betalain: the red pigment in beetroot cells; it leaks out when the membranes become more permeable.
  • Membrane permeability: how easily substances can pass through a membrane; alcohol and high temperature increase it.
  • Colorimeter: an instrument that measures the absorbance or transmission of light by a solution, giving quantitative data.
  • Haemolysis: the bursting of red blood cells, used in one question as a measure of membrane damage.
  • Control: a treatment without the factor being tested, such as saline with no alcohol, used as a baseline for comparison.

What these questions cover

Every question on this page is set on Core Practical 2 or Core Practical 3 of the Pearson Edexcel A level Biology A (Salters-Nuffield) specification (9BN0).

  • Core Practical 2: Investigate the vitamin C content of food and drink.
  • Core Practical 3: Investigate membrane structure, including the effect of alcohol concentration or temperature on membrane permeability.

How to use this page

Write your answer on paper before you open the mark scheme. Allow about 1.2 minutes per mark: the 15 questions are worth 48 marks, so about 58 minutes in total. Then mark your answer strictly against the mark scheme and read the examiners' tip underneath it. If you'd rather print the questions, download the PDF pack.

Core Practical 2: testing for vitamin C

Question 1

AS Paper 1 · June 2022 · Q2(b)(i) · 2 marks

Name a reagent that shows vitamin C is present and give its colour change.

Exam question: (i) Complete the table to show the details of a reagent that could be used to show if vitamin C was present. (2) Colour change observed Reagent name if vitamin C present to
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: Reagent colour change 2(b)(i) correct named reagent (1) • name observed if vitamin C present • correct colour change (1) DCPIP blue to colourless starch/iodide yellow-brown to solution blue-black (2)

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most students answered correctly, usually with DCPIP, although a few used starch/iodide solution. The most common incorrect reagent was phenolphthalein.

Question 2

AS Paper 1 · June 2022 · Q2(b)(ii) · 2 marks

State and justify one variable to control when fruits are stored after picking.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: State and justify one variable that should have been controlled when the fruits were stored after picking.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 2(b)(ii) An answer that makes reference to the following: e.g. temperature • suitable variable to control (1) e.g. description of {effect on • correct justification (1) vitamin C content / how it would increase the validity of the data} e.g. temperature is a factor that can {increase / decrease} percentage of vitamin C

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Temperature was the most common answer; better answers explained how a different storage temperature would increase or decrease the vitamin C content. Answers about growing conditions showed the question had not been read carefully.

Core Practical 2: devising a vitamin C investigation

Question 3

AS Paper 1 · June 2018 · Q3(b) · 5 marks

Devise an investigation to collect the vitamin C data shown in the graph.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: Devise an investigation that can be used to collect these data.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 3(b) An answer that makes reference to five of the following:  titration using DCPIP (1) ALLOW description of titration  (using) {known/ same} volume of {fruit juice / DCPIP} (1)  method for controlling another relevant variable (1) e.g. concentration of DCPIP, age of fruit juice  method for determining a suitable

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Adding drops of juice or DCPIP from a pipette was not credited as a titration. If the volume of juice is your dependent variable you cannot also control it. Only 5% explained how to determine the vitamin C concentration from their results.

Question 4

AS Paper 1 · June 2019 · Q4(b) · 4 marks · Hard

Devise a method to measure how the vitamin C concentration of breast milk changes during a feed.

Exam question: Milk at the start of a feed does not contain any vitamin C. Milk at the end of a feed can contain 10 mg of vitamin C per 100 cm3 of milk. Milk samples were taken at different times during the course of one feed. Devise a method to measure how the concentration of vitamin C change
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 4(b) An answer that makes reference to four of the following: • five samples of breast milk tested from different points of feed (1) e.g. volume of breast milk taken to • description of titration of breast milk using DCPIP (1) decolourise the DCPIP ALLOW volume of DCPIP taken to produce a colour change in milk e.g. vol

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many tested only one sample instead of at least five from different points in the feed. Counting drops from a dropping pipette was not enough for a titration. Standardising the titration technique was the most commonly awarded point.

Question 5

A level Paper 1 · June 2019 · Q4(b) · 4 marks

Devise a procedure to investigate the effect of cooking on the vitamin C content of cauliflower.

Exam question: Devise a procedure that can be used to investigate the effect of cooking on the vitamin C content of cauliflower.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 4(b) An answer that makes reference to the following: • cauliflower extract from same mass (of cooked and ALLOW cauliflower extracts of the same uncooked cauliflower) (1) concentration produced • description of titration of cauliflower extract with e.g. volume of cauliflower extract taken to DCPIP (1) decolourise the D

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Several lost a mark by cooking the cauliflower at a range of temperatures or times without testing uncooked cauliflower. Use terms such as mass and volume, not 'amount' or 'drops'.

Question 6

AS Paper 1 · June 2025 · Q4(b) · 5 marks · Easy

Devise an investigation to test whether broccoli loses less vitamin C when steamed than when boiled.

Exam question: The photograph shows green broccoli being cooked in a steamer. (Source: © Art Directors & TRIP / Alamy Stock Photo) Broccoli can also be cooked by boiling in water. A student investigated the following hypothesis: ‘The broccoli will lose less vitamin C if it is steamed than if it
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An answer that makes reference to the following: ignore amount 4(b) • control of a biotic variable (1) e.g. same age, same type, same mass, same surface area, same broccoli plant • control of an appropriate abiotic variable (1) e.g. same volume of water, same cooking time, concentration of DCPIP, buffer • valid method

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most described a DCPIP titration correctly. Higher-level answers controlled both biotic and abiotic variables and compared the vitamin C content with uncooked broccoli.

Question 7

A level Paper 2 · June 2024 · Q2(c) · 4 marks

Devise an investigation to compare the vitamin C content of solutions from fresh and frozen cow liver.

Exam question: Many mammals such as cows can synthesise vitamin C from glucose in the liver. Vitamin C solutions can be prepared from fresh or frozen cow liver. Devise an investigation to compare the vitamin C content of these solutions.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 2(c) An answer that makes reference to four of the following: • use same volume of solution (for both) / use same { volume / concentration } of DCPIP (for both) (1) • add solution to DCPIP / titration using DCPIP and ALLOW add DCPIP to each solution {vitamin C solution / extract} (1) • until DCPIP {decolourises / chang

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: The two solutions were given, but a number of candidates described how to make them. Know the colour change: if DCPIP is added to the vitamin C solution, the end point is when the DCPIP colour no longer changes.

Core Practical 3: explaining permeability results

Question 8

A level Paper 2 · June 2022 · Q8(d) · 3 marks

Explain why alcohol affects the concentration of betalain in beetroot cells.

Exam question: Beetroot cells contain the pigment betalain. When beetroot cells are placed in alcohol, the concentration of betalain in the cells changes. Explain why alcohol affects the concentration of betalain in these cells.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 8(d) An explanation that makes reference to three of the following: decreases betalain concentration (in the cells) • (1) due to betalain {diffusing out / moving down a • concentration gradient} (1) (because) the alcohol increases membrane IGNORE reference to cell wall • permeability (1) membrane {lipids/ phospholipids

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many did not answer in the context of the pigment concentration inside the cells, and some thought betalain moved out by osmosis. Say how permeability changes, and that membrane phospholipids dissolve in alcohol.

Question 9

AS Paper 1 · June 2023 · Q8(c)(ii) · 2 marks

Explain the effect of ethanol concentration on the colour of the solution around beetroot.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: The relative colour of the ethanol after 30 minutes was measured using a colorimeter. The results of the investigation are shown in the graph. Relative colour of the ethanol solution Concentration of ethanol Explain the results of this investigation.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An explanation that makes reference to two of the 8(c)(ii) following: • permeability of membrane increases as ethanol increases in concentration (1) • ethanol disrupts membrane (structure) (1) ALLOW ethanol {dissolves lipids / denatures proteins} in membrane ALLOW ethanol increases membrane fluidity • (therefore) more

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: A significant minority described the graph instead of explaining it. The most common mark was for ethanol disrupting the membrane; better answers explained that more betalain could then leave the cells.

Question 10

AS Paper 1 · November 2021 · Q6(c)(i) · 1 mark

Plot a colorimeter result for 0.5% detergent on the graph.

Exam question: The colour of the 0.5% detergent solution was 0.25 a.u. Plot this result on the graph.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: Example of plot: 6 (c)(i) correctly plotted point on graph (1) (1) 8BN0_01 QPEC Version 17

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most plotted the point correctly, but a significant minority plotted 0.5 a.u. at 0.25% instead. Take care not to miss out questions like this.

Core Practical 3: controls and evaluation

Question 11

AS Paper 1 · June 2024 · Q4(c)(i) · 2 marks

State and justify a suitable control for the alcohol and red blood cell investigation.

Exam question: State and justify a suitable control for this investigation.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An answer that makes reference to the following: 4(c)(i) • saline / solution with no alcohol / 0.00% alcohol solution / ignore {(distilled) water / no {solvent / saline} used to dilute alcohol solutions (1) alcohol} unqualified to calculate percentage of cells which have undergone ALLOW baseline value to compare • haem

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many confused a control with a controlled variable. Distilled water is unsuitable because it would also cause the red blood cells to haemolyse.

Question 12

AS Paper 1 · June 2024 · Q4(c)(ii) · 4 marks

Evaluate the effect of the concentration of three alcohols on haemolysis of red blood cells.

Exam question: Evaluate the effect of concentration of the three alcohols on the haemolysis of red blood cells.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An answer that makes reference to four of the following: 4(c)(ii) • increasing concentration of alcohol increases the percentage ALLOW increased number instead of of red blood cells that have haemolysed (1) percentage of cells ALLOW positive correlation • {most / largest increase in} haemolysis with butanol / least hae

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Use the alcohol formulae as well as the graph: many linked haemolysis to the size of the molecule. Relatively few used their knowledge of the core practical to explain the effect on membranes or commented on the method.

Question 13

AS Paper 1 · June 2017 · Q4(c) · 2 marks

Explain one way in which the temperature investigation could be improved.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: Explain one way in which this investigation could be improved.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An explanation that makes reference to the following: Check that the justification 4 (c) matches the improvement  One for improvement (1) suggested - repeats at each temperature - standardised {BCB concentration / red blood cell count / immersion time} - smaller temperature intervals - use of colorimeter  And one for

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Repeats and a colorimeter were the most common improvements; justify a colorimeter by its quantitative data and spell it correctly. Extending the temperature range was not accepted, but smaller temperature intervals were.

Core Practical 3: devising a permeability investigation

Question 14

AS Paper 1 · June 2023 · Q8(c)(iii) · 4 marks

Devise a valid investigation to compare the effects of ethanol and propanol on beetroot membranes.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: Devise a valid investigation to compare the effects of ethanol and propanol on the permeability of beetroot membranes.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: An answer that makes reference to the following: 8(c)(iii) • use of {same / 5} concentration(s) for ethanol and propanol (1) • description of how an appropriate variable can be eg use same {beetroot / species / age} / controlled (1) use core borer to get same diameter / use water bath to maintain temperature / use stop

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most used the same concentrations of each alcohol and a valid way to measure colour. Fewer described how a variable is controlled or what to do with the raw data. Adding both alcohols to the same tube was not credited.

Question 15

AS Paper 1 · June 2016 · Q3(b) · 4 marks

Devise an investigation into whether plant age affects membrane permeability in red cabbage leaves.

Exam question: Anthocyanins are purple pigments found in the cells of red cabbage leaves. A student investigated the following hypothesis: ‘The permeability of cell membranes in a red cabbage leaf is affected by the age of the plant.’ Devise an investigation the student could use to test this h
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 3(b) An answer that makes reference to four of the following: Ignore descriptions of beetroot core practical  (red) cabbages of at least five different ages used (1)  (red) cabbage leaves with same { surface area / mass / source } (1)  description of how another relevant variable is controlled Allow either growing c

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many described the beetroot practical but did not apply it to cabbage leaves of different ages. Think about a suitable range for the independent variable and explain how other variables are controlled.

Where students lose marks (from Pearson examiners' reports and mark schemes)

Each point below comes from the examiners' reports and mark schemes, and is followed by wording that gained marks.

  • Phenolphthalein is not a vitamin C test. The most common incorrect reagent was phenolphthalein.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'DCPIP, which changes from blue to colourless if vitamin C is present.'

  • Storage conditions, not growing conditions. Some answers referred to growing conditions for the plants instead of storage after picking.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Temperature, because temperature can increase or decrease the percentage of vitamin C.'

  • Counting drops is not a titration. Many just counted how many drops from a dropping pipette caused a colour change.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Titration of breast milk using DCPIP, e.g. the volume of breast milk taken to decolourise the DCPIP.'

  • Turn the volume into a concentration. Only 5% explained how the concentration of vitamin C could be determined.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Determine the concentration of vitamin C using a calibration curve, then calculate the vitamin C per 100 g.'

  • Test the uncooked vegetable too. Several cooked the cauliflower at a range of temperatures or times but left out uncooked cauliflower.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Cauliflower extract from the same mass of cooked and uncooked cauliflower.'

  • Betalain diffuses out, not by osmosis. Some thought betalain moved out of the cells by osmosis.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'The alcohol increases membrane permeability, so betalain diffuses out down a concentration gradient.'

  • Distilled water haemolyses red cells too. Students who gave a control often chose distilled water, which would also cause haemolysis.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Saline with no alcohol, to see if cells undergo haemolysis in the absence of alcohol.'

  • Narrow the intervals, don't extend the range. Extending the range of temperatures was not accepted as an improvement.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'Smaller temperature intervals, to determine the temperature at which active transport was affected.'

Download the questions

Download the PDF pack (15 questions, mark schemes at the end)

Keep practising

Questions, mark schemes and examiners' report extracts © Pearson Education Ltd.

Previous
Previous

Enzyme Concentration and Initial Rates (Core Practical 4): Edexcel SNAB A Level Biology Exam Questions

Next
Next

Caffeine and Daphnia Heart Rate (Core Practical 1): Edexcel SNAB A Level Biology Exam Questions