Variation (17.1): Cambridge (CIE) A Level Biology 9700 Exam Questions by Topic

Variation is sub-topic 17.1 of Topic 17, Selection and evolution, in the Cambridge International AS & A Level Biology syllabus (9700). You need to explain, with examples, that phenotypic variation is due to genetic factors, environmental factors or a combination of the two. You need to explain what is meant by discontinuous variation and continuous variation, explain the genetic basis of each, and use the t-test to compare the means of two different samples; the formula for the t-test is provided. This is A level content, examined on Paper 4.

The examiners' reports return to the same points. Phenotype is affected by genes, by the environment and by the interaction of the two, and few students mention the interaction. When a table of data is given, compare different breeds in the same place to show a genetic cause and the same breed in different places to show an environmental cause, and quote figures with their units. Give each difference between discontinuous and continuous variation as a matched pair. Do not confuse genes with alleles when you describe the genetic basis of variation, and do not write about the environment when the question asks for the genetic basis. After a t-test, say that the difference is significant.

Studying Cambridge International A level Biology and want more help? Tom teaches CIE students one-to-one online, including students in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Hong Kong, India and Indonesia, and every lesson is recorded. You can book a one-to-one lesson or a free 15-minute discovery chat, or register your interest in a CIE group class starting in September 2027, using the links at the bottom of this page.

What you need from AS Level

Each question on this page assumes you're secure on these ideas. If any of them feels shaky, look it up before you start.

  • A gene is a sequence of nucleotides in DNA that codes for a polypeptide.
  • A gene mutation is a change in the sequence of base pairs in DNA and may result in an altered polypeptide.
  • The mean of a sample is the sum of the values divided by the number of values.
  • Give a calculated answer to the number of significant figures or decimal places that the question asks for.

Key terms

These words come up in the questions and mark schemes. Examiners expect you to use them exactly.

  • Phenotypic variation: the differences in phenotype between the individuals of a species; it is caused by genetic factors, environmental factors or a combination of both.
  • Discontinuous variation: variation in which the phenotypes fall into a few distinct categories with no intermediates, such as blood groups.
  • Continuous variation: variation in which the phenotypes form a range of values with many intermediates, such as height or body mass; it often gives a normal distribution.
  • Polygenic: controlled by many genes; the different genes have an additive effect on the phenotype.
  • Additive effect: each of several genes adds a small amount to the phenotype, so their effects combine.
  • t-test: a statistical test used to compare the means of two different samples.
  • Critical value: the value that t is compared with; if the calculated value of t is greater, the difference between the two means is significant.
  • Significant difference: a difference between two means that is not due to chance.

What these questions cover (Cambridge 9700 Topic 17: Selection and evolution)

The questions test these learning outcomes from sub-topic 17.1 of the Cambridge International AS & A Level Biology syllabus (9700) for 2025 to 2027.

  • 17.1.1 explain, with examples, that phenotypic variation is due to genetic factors or environmental factors or a combination of genetic and environmental factors
  • 17.1.2 explain what is meant by discontinuous variation and continuous variation
  • 17.1.3 explain the genetic basis of discontinuous variation and continuous variation
  • 17.1.4 use the t-test to compare the means of two different samples

How to use this page

Write your answer on paper before you open the mark scheme. Allow about 1.2 minutes per mark: the 22 questions are worth 54 marks, so about 65 minutes in total. Then mark your answer strictly against the mark scheme and read the examiners' tip underneath it. If you'd rather print the questions, download the PDF pack.

Genetic and environmental causes of variation (17.1.1)

Question 1

Paper 4 · May/June 2024 (42) · Q2(a) · 3 marks · Hard

Describe the main factors that cause phenotypic variation.

Exam question: Phenotypic variation exists in many forms and has a number of possible causes. Describe the main factors that are the cause of phenotypic variation.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 1 genetic / genotype / alleles or example ; mutation / crossing over / independent assortment / random fertilisation / random mating 2 environmental or example ; climate / disease / food availability / soil pH / selection pressure 3 combination / interaction, of genes and environment or example ; gene (expression) is m

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many said that phenotype is affected by both environmental and genetic factors. Few went on to say that the interaction of genetic and environmental factors is important.

Question 2

Paper 4 · May/June 2024 (43) · Q2(a) · 3 marks · Hard

Decide whether each example of variation is due to genetic factors, environmental factors or both.

Exam question: Some examples of phenotypic variation in plants and animals are described in Table 2.1. Complete Table 2.1 by stating whether the cause of variation for each described example is likely to be due to: • genetic factors, VG • environmental factors, VE • a combination of genetic and
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: description of phenotypic variation cause of variation Tomato plants grown in a glasshouse and grown outside VG + VE vary in the yield of tomatoes they produce. Seventeen genes associated with tomato yield have been identified. New strawberry plants from the variety called Sweet Ann are VE made by asexual reproduction.

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: The strawberry plants were made by asexual reproduction, so they are genetically identical and the cause is environmental only: this was the most common error. For the tomato plants, the seventeen genes linked to yield show that there is a genetic cause as well as an environmental one.

Question 3

Paper 4 · October/November 2020 (42) · Q2(b)(i) · 2 marks

Explain how the table supports the claim that some of the variation in milk yield in goats is genetic.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: (i) Explain how the data in Table 2.1 support the claim that some of the variation in mean daily milk yield in goats is due to genetic causes.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 different breeds at, same / named, location / environmental conditions, / have different milk yields ; 2 comparative data quote including units ; 3 (different breeds have) different gene pools / different alleles ; 4 due to selective breeding ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Compare different breeds in the same location. Quote figures with their units, and write 'breeds', not 'goats' or 'goat species'. Very few said that different breeds have different gene pools.

Question 4

Paper 4 · October/November 2020 (42) · Q2(b)(ii) · 2 marks

Explain how the table shows that environmental factors can cause variation in milk yield in goats.

Exam question: The climate, vegetation and availability of veterinary care for goats in Northern Europe, Barbados and South Africa are different. Explain how Table 2.1 shows that environmental factors can cause variation in mean daily milk yield in goats.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 same breed has different milk yields in, different location / named location / environmental conditions; 2 comparative data quote including units ; 3 how, climate / vegetation / veterinary care, affects milk yield ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Compare the same breed in different locations. Say how the environment affects the yield, not just that it 'affects' it. Many did not quote the data correctly, and a significant number wrote the explanation the wrong way round.

Question 5

Paper 4 · May/June 2019 (42) · Q2(b) · 3 marks

Suggest and explain three ways in which the tank environment may make a captive fish different from a wild fish.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: Suggest and explain three ways in which the tank environment may make the phenotype of a captive fish different from a wild fish.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any three from: captive fish: 1 controlled conditions so phenotype less varied ; 2 more oxygen so larger ; 3 less space / overcrowding, so smaller ; 4 less space / overcrowding, so (signs of) disease / wounds ; 5 food qualified linked to, size / muscle / fat ; 6 AVP ; e.g. named tank condition linked to skin colour / n

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Link each condition in the tank to a stated difference in phenotype: naming the condition alone, or saying only that the phenotype would differ, was too vague. This is not a question about speciation or selection pressures.

Discontinuous and continuous variation (17.1.2)

Question 6

Paper 4 · October/November 2024 (42) · Q5(a) · 4 marks

Tick the statements that apply to discontinuous variation and to continuous variation.

Exam question: Variation in a particular characteristic can be described as either discontinuous or continuous. Table 5.1 contains a list of statements that apply to discontinuous variation, continuous variation or both. Complete both columns of Table 5.1. Put a tick (✓) in the box if the state
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: statement discontinuous continuous variation variation  often involves one gene only  environmental factors may affect gene expression  there is an additive effect of genes that contributes to the phenotype  there are distinct differences between the various forms of a ;;;; characteristic

Tap an image to open it full size.

Question 7

Paper 4 · May/June 2023 (42) · Q3(a)(i) · 1 mark · Easy

Name the type of variation shown by winged and wingless fruits.

Exam question: A large sample of sea blush fruits was collected and their fruit-wing characteristic was recorded. Name the type of variation that is shown for the fruit-wing characteristic of the sea blush.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: discontinuous ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most gave discontinuous. Wrong answers included phenotypic variation and genetic variation.

Question 8

Paper 4 · February/March 2023 (42) · Q3(a) · 3 marks · Easy

Explain what is meant by continuous variation and how it can be caused.

Exam question: Within any population of salmon there is variation in body mass. This is an example of continuous variation. Explain what is meant by continuous variation and how it can be caused.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any three from: max two from: 1 (phenotype has) range of values / intermediates ; 2 (phenotypes) not, in groups / in classes / categoric / discrete / qualitative or (phenotypes are) quantitative ; 3 normal distribution ; max two from: 4 polygenic / controlled by many genes ; 5 different genes / alleles, have additive e

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most described continuous variation very well. A few did not go on to say how it is caused.

Question 9

Paper 4 · October/November 2023 (41) · Q3(b) · 2 marks · Easy

Suggest two reasons why a student concluded that flower colour shows continuous variation.

Exam question: The Japanese morning glory, I. nil, has over 20 different flower colour phenotypes, including shades of blue, purple, red and pink. The flower colour of I. nil is controlled by at least four genes. The flower colour can change gradually after the flowers open each morning and can
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 colours / shades / categories / phenotypes, not distinct / not discrete / overlap / form a (gradual) range / include intermediates ; 2 >1 / 4 / several / many, genes ; 3 environment affects, it / colour / phenotype ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Use the information given: several genes, an effect of the environment, and colours that form a gradual range. The weakest answers described single flowers changing colour and not the range of phenotypes in the whole population.

Question 10

Paper 4 · October/November 2019 (42) · Q2(a) · 2 marks

Explain why the variation in armour plating in stickleback fish can be described as discontinuous.

Exam question: Explain why the variation in armour plating in stickleback fish can be described as discontinuous.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 discrete / distinct, categories / phenotypes / morphs / groups ; A (only) 3 groups 2 no range of phenotypes / no intermediates / no normal distribution ; 3 (only) one gene / only EDA, involved ; 4 not affected by environment ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most gave discrete categories and stopped there. Go on to say that there are no intermediates, that the environment has no effect, or that a single gene is involved: write 'gene', not 'genes'.

Types of variation and their genetic basis (17.1.1 to 17.1.3)

Question 11

Paper 4 · May/June 2024 (41) · Q9(a) · 2 marks · Hard

State two differences between discontinuous variation and continuous variation, other than the genetic basis.

Exam question: Within a species, the variation that is observed for a particular characteristic can be described as discontinuous or continuous. Discontinuous variation has a different genetic basis from continuous variation. State two differences between discontinuous variation and continuous
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: discontinuous continuous (forms / phenotypes / categories) (forms / phenotypes / categories) not distinct / not distinct / discrete / categoric / do not overlap / do not form discrete / overlap / form a (gradual) range / include a (gradual) range / no intermediates / two or few intermediates / many differ

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Give a feature of one type with the matching feature of the other. Some wrote about the genetic basis, which the question ruled out. 'Quantitative' and 'qualitative' did not work here, because in both cases you count the individuals with each phenotype.

Question 12

Paper 4 · May/June 2024 (41) · Q9(b) · 2 marks

Suggest the genetic basis of the variation in colour pattern in the harlequin ladybird.

Exam question: Fig. 9.1 shows three of the colour patterns seen in H. axyridis and the percentage of each in a population. colour pattern conspicua spectabilis succinea percentage 5 13 82 Fig. 9.1 Suggest the genetic basis of the variation in colour pattern in H. axyridis.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 one / two, genes (control colour pattern) ; 2 different alleles of a gene have a large effect ; 3 multiple / three, alleles ; 4 gene interaction / epistasis ; 5 AVP ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Some only repeated that the variation is discontinuous, which is stated at the start of the question. The points most often credited were control by one or two genes, and different alleles at a single locus having large effects.

Question 13

Paper 4 · May/June 2024 (41) · Q9(c) · 2 marks · Easy

State two environmental factors that may affect adult body size in the harlequin ladybird.

Exam question: The body size of adult H. axyridis varies from 5 mm to 8 mm. Adult ladybirds do not grow or change size. Adults develop from larvae that hatch from eggs. State two environmental factors that may affect adult body size in H. axyridis.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 temperature / food (supply) ; 2 of larva / during larval development ; 3 egg size / diet of mother / size of mother ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most gained credit for food availability or temperature. The best answers used the question and said that these factors act through growth at the larval stage.

Question 14

Paper 4 · October/November 2025 (41) · Q2(b)(ii) · 1 mark

Name the type of variation shown by the F2 maize plants in the graph.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: State the name of the type of variation shown by the maize F2 generation in Fig. 2.1.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: continuous ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

Question 15

Paper 4 · October/November 2025 (41) · Q2(b)(iii) · 4 marks

Explain the genetic basis of the type of variation shown by the F2 maize plants.

Exam question: Explain the genetic basis of the type of variation shown by the maize F2 generation.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any four from: 1 many / different / several / multiple, genes ; 2 affect, same trait / (percentage) area of leaf damage / resistance ; 3 alleles of, one / each, gene have a small effect ; 4 (different) genes have, additive / combined / interactive, effects ; 5 mathematical treatment to illustrate additive effect ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

Question 16

Paper 4 · May/June 2021 (42) · Q8(a) · 3 marks

Describe the genetic basis for continuous variation.

Exam question: In continuous variation, a population shows a range of phenotypes between two extremes with no distinct groups. Height and mass are examples of phenotypic traits that show continuous variation. Describe the genetic basis for continuous variation.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 1 different alleles at a single gene locus have small effects (on the phenotype) ; 2 different genes may have an, additive / combined, effect (on the phenotype) ; 3 ref. to multiple genes / polygenes / description ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Many confused alleles and genes: different alleles at a single gene locus have small effects, and different genes have an additive effect. A large number wrote about the environment, which did not answer the question.

Question 17

Paper 4 · May/June 2021 (42) · Q8(b) · 2 marks

Suggest two environmental factors that may affect the body mass of an animal.

Exam question: Environmental factors can contribute to continuous variation. Suggest two environmental factors that may affect the body mass of an animal.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: any two from: 1 quantity / availability, of, food / nutrients ; A competition for food 2 quality of food / malnutrition ; 3 disease ; 4 temperature ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: 'Climate' or 'diet' on their own were too vague. Give the quantity or quality of food, disease or temperature. Exercise was a common wrong answer.

The t-test (17.1.4)

Question 18

Paper 4 · February/March 2023 (42) · Q3(b)(i) · 3 marks · Easy

Calculate the value of t for the body mass of salmon with and without injections of growth hormone.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: Calculate the value of t for the results shown in Table 3.1 using the formula for the t-test: xr - xr t = 1 2 f s2 s2 p 1 2 n + n 1 2 Give your answer to two decimal places. Show your working. t =
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: difference between means = 9.4 – 7.7 or 1.7 ; 0.42 + 1.12 denominator = 28 27 or 0.16 + 1.21 28 27 or 0.22 / 0.23 (no limit on number of decimal places) ; t = 7.56 ; must be to 2 decimal places allow ECF

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most calculated t correctly. The errors were using a negative value for the numerator and forgetting to take the square root of the denominator.

Question 19

Paper 4 · February/March 2023 (42) · Q3(b)(ii) · 3 marks · Easy

Comment on how far the t-test supports the student's conclusion.

Exam question: The critical value at p = 0.05 for these data is 2.01. The student used the results in Table 3.1 and the t-test to conclude that the injections of recombinant growth hormone cause an increase in the growth rate of the non-GM salmon. Comment on the extent to which the conclusion m
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 1 t-value / 7.56, is greater than, 2.01 / critical value ; 2 difference between two groups is, significant / not due to chance or null hypothesis rejected ; any two from: 3 overlap in, data range / error bars ; 4 ref. to correlation does not prove causation ; 5 only a single investigation / needs repeating / small samp

Tap an image to open it full size.

From the examiners' report: Most interpreted the t-test correctly, but the wording did not always give the idea of statistical significance. Few considered that, at a probability of 0.05, 5% of tests where there is no real difference would still show a difference.

The t-test in a vitamin D study (17.1.4 and 17.1.1)

Question 20

Paper 4 · October/November 2024 (42) · Q5(b)(ii) · 3 marks

Calculate the value of t, to four significant figures, for vitamin D in summer and in winter.

Information from earlier in this question:

Earlier part of the same exam question, giving the information this part uses. Exam question: The t‑test was used to compare the mean concentration of serum 25‑OHD when sampled during the summer with the mean concentration of serum 25‑OHD when sampled during the winter, as shown in Table 5.2. Calculate the value of t using the formula provided. x - x key to symbols: t = 1
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: t = 4.255 ;;; give 2 marks: if answer is 4.25 or 4.26 if answer is more than 4 significant figures e.g. 4.255439871 if answer is incorrectly rounded to 4 significant figures e.g. 4.256 if answer incorrect then max 2 for working numerator = 4.2 denominator = 0.986972 ecf - if no working mark given then allow one mark fo

Tap an image to open it full size.

Question 21

Paper 4 · October/November 2024 (42) · Q5(b)(iii) · 3 marks

State the conclusion from the study and explain how your value of t supports it.

Exam question: The critical value at the 0.0001 probability level is 3.773. State the conclusion that can be made about the results of the study shown in Table 5.2 and explain how the result of your calculation in (b)(ii) can be used to support this conclusion.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: 1 there is a higher (mean) concentration of serum 25-OHD in summer ; ora any two from: 2 value of t / 4.255 > critical value / 3.773 ; 3 there is a significant difference between the two means ; 4 any difference is not due to chance / difference due to chance less than 0.0001% ; ecf from incorrect answer to 5bii

Tap an image to open it full size.

Question 22

Paper 4 · October/November 2024 (42) · Q5(b)(iv) · 1 mark

Suggest the likely causes of variation in the quantity of vitamin D stored in the body in this sample of women.

Exam question: Suggest the likely causes of variation in quantity of vitamin D stored in the body in this sample of women.
Show the mark scheme Mark scheme: genetic AND environmental OR an example of a genetic cause AND an example of an environmental cause ;

Tap an image to open it full size.

Where students lose marks (from Cambridge examiners' reports and mark schemes)

Each point below comes from the examiners' reports and mark schemes, and is followed by wording that gained marks.

  • Genes and environment interact. Students said that phenotype is affected by genetic and environmental factors and stopped there.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'genetic', 'environmental' and a 'combination / interaction, of genes and environment', for example 'gene (expression) is modified by environment'.

  • Asexual reproduction means the same genes. Students gave a genetic cause for variation in strawberry plants made by asexual reproduction, or environment only for tomato yield.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'VE' for the strawberry plants and 'VG + VE' for the tomato plants.

  • Same place for genes, same breed for environment. Students did not compare the right groups, wrote 'goats' when they meant breeds, or quoted figures without units.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'different breeds at same location have different milk yields' for genetic causes; 'same breed has different milk yields in different location' for the environment; each with a 'comparative data quote including units'.

  • Link the condition to the phenotype. Students described the conditions in the tank without saying how the phenotype of the fish would differ, or wrote about speciation.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'more oxygen so larger', 'less space / overcrowding, so smaller', or food 'linked to size / muscle / fat'.

  • Give differences in matched pairs. Students gave a feature of one type of variation without the matching feature of the other, or wrote about the genetic basis.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'discrete' and 'no intermediates' against 'form a (gradual) range' and 'include intermediates'; 'not a normal distribution' against 'normal distribution'; 'no / little, effect from environment' against 'some / large, effect from environment'.

  • Discontinuous is not a genetic basis. Students only repeated that the variation in colour pattern is discontinuous.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'one / two, genes' control the colour pattern and 'different alleles of a gene have a large effect'.

  • Alleles have small effects, genes add up. Students confused alleles with genes, or wrote about the environment when asked for the genetic basis of continuous variation.

    ✔ Gains credit: 'different alleles at a single gene locus have small effects', 'different genes may have an additive / combined effect', and a reference to 'multiple genes / polygenes'.

  • Say the difference is significant. Students compared t with the critical value but their wording did not give the idea of statistical significance.

    ✔ Gains credit: the 't-value is greater than critical value', so the 'difference between two groups is significant / not due to chance'.

Download the questions

Download the PDF pack (22 questions, mark schemes at the end)

Keep practising

Questions, mark schemes and examiners' report extracts © Cambridge University Press & Assessment.