Cambridge (CIE) A Level Biology Paper 5: How Planning, Analysis and Evaluation Is Marked

Paper 5 of Cambridge International AS & A Level Biology (9700) is Planning, Analysis and Evaluation. It is a written A level paper worth 30 marks. The marks are for skills, not recall. This guide uses the Paper 5 mark schemes and examiners' reports from recent series to show how those skills are marked and where marks are lost.

Want one-to-one help with Cambridge Biology? Tom teaches CIE students one-to-one online, including students in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Hong Kong, India and Indonesia, and every lesson is recorded. Book a one-to-one lesson or a free 15-minute discovery chat, or register your interest in a CIE group class starting in September 2027.

What Paper 5 tests

The syllabus lists five skills for Paper 5. The pages linked below group real Paper 5 questions under these headings.

How a planning answer is marked

The long planning question is marked from a numbered list of points. The mark scheme begins 'any seven from' (or five, or six) and each point that appears in your answer earns one mark. A typical list has points for:

  • how the independent variable is changed, with enough values: 'use a minimum of five' light intensities, or 'minimum 5 cubes with different' sizes;
  • how the dependent variable is measured, for example the distance the meniscus 'moves along the capillary tube' 'in a fixed time';
  • each variable that is kept the same, and how: 'same / stated' volume, or a 'method of maintaining the same temperature';
  • repeats: 'use at least three measurements' 'and calculate a mean';
  • safety, as a single point: 'named hazard and risk and precaution'.

The examiners' reports say that the best plans are clear and concise, often with numbered steps, and give volumes, times and temperatures. Weaker plans repeat details from the question, include steps the question said to leave out, or list variables without saying how each one is controlled. Only limited credit is available for safety, so a full description of every possible hazard does not gain extra marks. The reports also ask for scientific words: 'mean', not 'average', and 'volume', not 'amount'.

Where marks are lost, skill by skill

Defining the problem

  • Name the variable in a word or phrase. In one question the answer was 'species of tree'; a sentence beginning 'The undergrowth' made the undergrowth the independent variable and could not gain credit.
  • Be exact about what is changed. 'Vaccination against Rotavirus' was too vague for an independent variable; the mark scheme has 'vaccinated or not vaccinated'.
  • On a sketch graph the mark scheme asks for 'axes correctly labelled for independent and dependent variable'. The independent variable goes on the x-axis.

Methods

  • A control experiment is not a control variable. Many students described a variable that is kept constant when the question asked for a control.
  • When a question asks for two standardised variables, give two. Students who wrote lists often included the independent or dependent variable, and incorrect suggestions may cancel correct ones.
  • In a dilution, give the volume of stock solution and the volume of distilled water, with units, for every concentration.
  • In a risk assessment, the precaution must fit the risk. 'Wear gloves' did not always match the risk given, and 'harmful' was too general.

Dealing with data

  • Show your working: the mark scheme gives a mark for 'correct working'.
  • Say whether a percentage change is an increase or a decrease. One mark scheme gave a separate mark for 'decrease / minus'.
  • A null hypothesis for a correlation is 'no correlation between' the two variables. A common error was to write 'no difference'. For a t-test it is 'there is no difference' between the two means.
  • To justify a t-test, the mark scheme accepts 'comparing means' and 'continuous data'. The most common incorrect answer was that the data were discrete.

Conclusions

  • A conclusion says what the data show. Answers that only quoted figures from a graph did not gain the marks.
  • Use the statistics. When a result is not significant, the mark scheme has 'accept null hypothesis' or 'there is no significant difference'. Few students recognised this in one question.
  • Do not stop at 'the error bars do not overlap'. Say what it shows: the confidence intervals 'do not overlap', so the means are 'significantly different'. Write 'not significant', not 'insignificant'.
  • When a question asks whether data support a conclusion, give both sides. One mark scheme includes 'correlation does not indicate causation' as a reason not to support.

Evaluation

  • Look for limits in the investigation you are given. Mark schemes credit points such as 'no statistical test' and 'only one variety of potato investigated'.
  • An improvement needs a reason. One mark scheme pairs 'repeat investigation at least twice' with 'reduce effect of anomalies', and 'use marigold clones' with 'exclude genetic effects'.
  • Repeating a method without changing it does not necessarily improve the outcome. For better repeatability, the mark scheme wanted details such as 'same volume of water in each beaker' and 'use thermostatically controlled water-bath'.

What to do next

Work through the three Paper 5 pages above, then try whole papers under timed conditions from the Cambridge (CIE) 9700 past papers page. Everything else for the course is on the Cambridge (CIE) A Level Biology revision resources hub.

Mark scheme and examiners' report extracts © Cambridge University Press & Assessment.